TLDR
1. Must buy hospitalization insurance/integrated shield plan
2. BTIR (Buy Term, Invest the Rest)
3. Personally, I believe that CI/ECI riders are unnecessary
4. Forget about Endowment/ILP, use one of the robo-advisors or simply invest yourself
We wanted to get hospitalization insurance/integrated shield plan for Baby Ong as we deemed that to be the most important insurance one should get given the high cost of healthcare in Singapore.
The agent came with a bunch of other recommendations such as whole life, endowment and ILP. His rationale of getting a whole life is because it is the "cheapest" rate/premium one can get at age 0/1, pay 25 years get lifetime coverage, and cash value upon maturity. Endowment and ILP are to save up/invest for the baby education/university fees. I didn't buy it (both his recommendations and the policy). lol.

Let's just run through some numbers using the Aviva PI/product summary as a reference. The whole life insurance costs $1,408.50 and the early CI rider takes up the majority of the remaining premium at $732 per year. In my opinion, there's no need to get $300k ECI for the baby. CI is to cover the possible loss of income so that money will be the least of one's concern when one is recovering from it. Money is definitely not a problem for the baby. We would rather self-insure by saving the premium and investing them to grow our portfolio such that it will be big enough for us not to worry about money too.
These are the breakdown of the surrender/cash value for the whole life policy at different years before year 25 where the premium is no longer required.
Let's just assume using the best-case scenario of 4.75% investment return for the surrender/cash value of the policy. Compare the above with a BTIR (Buy Term, Invest the Rest) approach with a much higher coverage - $1 million.
The above is the premium breakdown for Tokio Marine $1 million term insurance with the various riders. Anyway, the one we got for Baby Ong is with TPD and a $100k CI rider because the system insisted that there must be a CI rider tied to it costs $385 per year.
A simple spreadsheet forecast will show the difference in the total premium paid (~$10k). If we were to invest the difference in premium (the remaining premium after 25 years for the term insurance will be paid out from the portfolio), our portfolio will grow to a sum larger than the surrender/cash value of the whole life policy with an assumption of 4.75%.
Take a look at the difference if we assume our investment will grow at 7% instead. Not forgetting if one were to surrender the whole life insurance to get the cash value, the coverage will cease while we can cash out anytime from the portfolio. It doesn't make sense to buy whole life insurance for the cash value. Play around with the spreadsheet and forecast them yourself -
Whole Life vs Term + Invest (For Baby)
Had we simply purchase what was recommended by the agent, the difference in terms of total premium paid (100% more) and portfolio would have been much greater! Having said that, it is not an apple to apple comparison given that the whole life has CI and ECI coverage and that's why I only compared using the whole life premium. Anyway, do take a look at this long article written by Kyith from Investment Moat too -
The True Reason to Choose Term Life Insurance Over Whole Life.
I will not recommend Endowment and ILP as a form of savings/investment for your baby's education fund. An endowment plan is simply too conservative for the baby with a long investment horizon (20+ years). ILP has extremely high fees. The worst part is both of them require you to commit for a long period of time. On the other hand, if you were to invest yourself or if you have no knowledge on how to invest, simply use any of the robo-advisors, you will have the flexibility to stop investing or cash out at any point in time without any penalty. I would say endowment was a popular choice for our parents' era where investing was much harder/challenging but it shouldn't be the case nowadays. There are much better alternatives.
Based on the above, we will be getting Baby Ong the $1 million term insurance and will be investing the difference of $100 per month into StashAway 36% risk index portfolio. Although it is the riskiest portfolio, we find it to be relatively safe across 20 years. It simply means there is a 1% chance at any given year that the portfolio might lose >=36% of the portfolio. You can read more about the risk index
here.
There's a 50% chance the portfolio might grow to $101k in 20 years time, 75% chance it will be $70k or 95% chance it will be just $41k considering the capital is just $24k. Unfortunately, we will only know the actual performance 20 years later.
 |
Our StashAway 22% Risk Index Cash Portfolio |
 |
My StashAway 36% Risk Index SRS Portfolio |
Why StashAway? I really like their portfolio. It is performing pretty well (notice the XIRR for both portfolios are double-digits as compared to the conservative 7% I used in the forecast above) and relatively safe (lower volatility and the max dropdown are within the respective risk index). Having said that, I had my reservation previously when I first found out about the 40% estate tax issue if one is to invest in the US market -
Estate Tax - The Issue Not Addressed By Some Robo Advisors.
However, given that they have openly indicated that a joint account is in the pipeline, I feel more confident that our investment will not be taxed if anything happens to me once I can set up the joint account with CZM. With that, we are now more comfortable with investing more money through StashAway.
Our Insurance and Investment Plan for Baby Ong:
1. Great Eastern GREAT SupremeHealth P PLUS + GREAT TotalCare Elite-P
2. Tokio Marine $1 million Term Insurance with TPD and $100 CI
3. $100 per month investment to StashAway 36% Risk Index Portfolio
In my opinion, if you are spending too much money on various insurance be it for yourself or your children, you will not be able to invest for your retirement. Instead, you will be helping the agent to retire. lol.
Anyway, if you are interested in signing up for StashAway, do use our referral link -
KPO and CZM Referral Link. You will get $10,000 free management fees for 6 months and we will get $16!
You might be interested in previous months update too:
Do like any of the following for the latest update/post!
1. FB Page -
KPO and CZM2. Twitter -
KPO and CZM3. Click
here to subscribe using email :)
4. Instagram -
KPO_and_CZM (Did you see those delicious food photos to the right --> Unfortunately, you can't see it on mobile.)